A very helpful article, particularly on the heresy of “Sola Papa.” Geoffrey Hull’s excellent historical analysis in “The Banished Heart,” and especially, his explanation of the Jesuit’s contribution to the development of papal absolutism was an eye-opener for me with regard to the permanent feature of “absolute and mindless obedience” in the Latin Church. Hull first clarified for me how our modern papal confusion (on the part of the faithful) might have begun. Thank you again for this piece.
(Just a little clarification: "solo papa" means "by the pope alone" and "solus papa" would mean "the pope alone"; "sola papa" won't work because "papa" is actually masculine.)
It was interesting yo read that you spoke with Kennedy Hall. I wonder what you think of Kennedy Hall's youtube offerings about the Charismatic movement, and in particular about Ralph Martin, the Companions of the Cross etc.
While I am not a fan of the Charismatic movement, and have wondered about the Baptism in the Holy Spirit, I find Hall's videos one sided.
Do you have an opinion on his take? On Twitter, Hall was surprised he was blocked by Rorate
I love the "iron grip" very much. And the reminder of occasions in the past where all seemed lost. We are blessed to live in these times so that we can sharpen our faith against the heavy wind we are facing... I have been sad today, my heart heavy ... But you made my day! Thank you, Peter.
A very helpful article, particularly on the heresy of “Sola Papa.” Geoffrey Hull’s excellent historical analysis in “The Banished Heart,” and especially, his explanation of the Jesuit’s contribution to the development of papal absolutism was an eye-opener for me with regard to the permanent feature of “absolute and mindless obedience” in the Latin Church. Hull first clarified for me how our modern papal confusion (on the part of the faithful) might have begun. Thank you again for this piece.
You're welcome! Glad you enjoyed it.
(Just a little clarification: "solo papa" means "by the pope alone" and "solus papa" would mean "the pope alone"; "sola papa" won't work because "papa" is actually masculine.)
It was interesting yo read that you spoke with Kennedy Hall. I wonder what you think of Kennedy Hall's youtube offerings about the Charismatic movement, and in particular about Ralph Martin, the Companions of the Cross etc.
While I am not a fan of the Charismatic movement, and have wondered about the Baptism in the Holy Spirit, I find Hall's videos one sided.
Do you have an opinion on his take? On Twitter, Hall was surprised he was blocked by Rorate
Caeli. Aren't you the editor of Rorate Caeli?
I'm not the editor, only a contributor. "New Catholic" (identity unknown) is the editor and the one who runs the Twitter account.
I am moderately critical of the charismatic movement, although as one who took part in it, I understand where they are coming from. See:
https://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2020/10/why-charismatic-catholics-should-love.html
https://onepeterfive.com/confusion-about-graces-a-catholic-critique-of-the-charismatic-movement/
I love the "iron grip" very much. And the reminder of occasions in the past where all seemed lost. We are blessed to live in these times so that we can sharpen our faith against the heavy wind we are facing... I have been sad today, my heart heavy ... But you made my day! Thank you, Peter.
I find the poem sarcastically hilarious, contrasting Pope Francis’ approach of matters within the Church to his approach of matters in the world.
Brilliant well reasoned essay on TLM, I pray to God they listen.
Note: that church is more beautiful than some cathedrals